Matt says: The following comment was taken from an unrelated Washington Times article. However, it is so full of interesting information and insightful that I thought it was worth reproducing here.
The comment is as follows:
"I have a feeling that Obama intends to provoke an attack by Iran on a US ship.
He is placing them directly in a place where Iranian shore batteries
armed with Sunburn missiles supplied by Russia or other smaller cargo
ships with a sunburn missile concealed in its cargo hold can destroy an
American carrier easily. Iran has conducted numerous tests launching
missiles from cargo holds of ships in recent years. With only 21 miles
across, and shipping lanes that are much narrower, the Strait of Hormuz
would allow insufficient time to launch effective countermeasures to a
Sunburn missile. Normal response time requires that the missile be
detected approximately 11 to 15 miles away in order to allow sufficient
response times to be able to effectively defend against the Sunburn with
95% effectiveness. Since the normal shipping lanes are only 2 to 3
miles wide, normal traffic will be in very close quarters in the
strait. A missile launched only 3 miles away would not allow sufficient
time for any type of effective response. A Sunburn travels at
approximately a half mile per second, so it would close the gap of 3
miles in just over 6 seconds. Far too close to mount an effective
defense. The only effective countermeasure to the Sunburn is Raytheon's SeaRAM Anti Ship Missile Defense System, but even that requires more than 6 seconds to deploy. I think that obama ordering American war ships into the Strait is placing our men
and women in harms way for political purposes. But I have little doubt
that obama is willing to sacrifice an American ship, perhaps even a US
carrier in order to get himself re elected. Can you imagine the outrage
Americans would feel if such an event were to happen? And then Obama
would get on TV and proclaim that the guilty will be forced to pay. The
public would eat it up. And most likely re elect him. Our fighting
men and women are mere pawns in Obama's eyes. He is already
repositioning two carriers in the gulf, and I presume a show of force
through the strait will be the order of the day. And of course all the
Generals and Admirals will be required to keep quiet on the fact that
Obama ordered the ships into such close quarters against the strong
recommendations of the joint Chiefs. That will be classified
information so as to deflect any blame from obama."
-- Harvybing,
source